Student Design Competition
The Student Design Competition has two primary goals:
- To provide graduate and undergraduate students with a hands-on introduction to HRI through a team-based design project.
- To engage students of diverse backgrounds working in technical, art/design, or social science disciplines.
The Design Challenge and Context
Building upon this year’s conference theme of Robots for Social Good, we select this year’s student design competition theme as Human-Agent Interaction and Practical Application for Enhancing Social Good. Student teams will develop interactive robotic objects that create or enhance social good. We encourage teams to identify and focus on a particular interaction context, develop their own interactive robotic objects, and create scenarios that illustrate how their robots fit within the lives of the humans involved.
Robots: We imagine teams sourcing small products from stores like IKEA or MUJI, hacking toys, or using everyday objects from their homes or labs, then actuating them using purchased or homemade hardware and software (perhaps using open-source tools) to add movement, visual indicators, or sound, so the robot can express itself and/or communicate its use or purpose. Don’t feel limited by any of these suggestions: be creative! The competition focuses less on demonstrations of technical proficiency and more on the design of compelling interactions that inspire, surprise, and delight.
Design: We recommend that teams consider the following design questions:
- In what setting(s) will the robot exist? Choose a real world setting that is familiar to your team. Possible settings include the home, office, city park, commuter train, car, and so on.
- Who are the stakeholders who live, work, travel, or relax in that setting?
- What activities do people engage in within those settings? Activities might range from commuting to working, exercising, sightseeing, or having a meal.
- How will the robot contribute to the activities that these people engage in, and what need(s) will it fill?
Competition: Teams will show their interactive robotic objects during the Student Design Competition session at the conference, and winners will be announced afterward. A jury of HRI luminaries will select winners in several categories. Conference attendees will also vote for their favorite entries during the Student Design Competition session.
- 20 December 2017: (12:00pm PDT) Submission deadline.
- 30 December 2017: Acceptance notifications.
- 15 January 2018: Camera ready versions due.
- 5–8 March 2018: The HRI 2018 conference. The preliminary date for the Student Design Competition is 8 March 2018. Winners will be announced during the conference.
Procedure: Teams should design, build and document their projects during the timeframe prior to the HRI 2018 conference. We encourage teams to photograph and video record their design and development process, to include as learnings during final presentations.
Participants: We invite students from all stages of their university careers, from undergraduate to postgraduate, and from any disciplinary focus area. While not required, we encourage multidisciplinary, even international, team membership.
Team Size: Please form teams of no more than 5 members. If your team has reason to exceed this number, please check with the Chairs at email@example.com first.
Registration: Registration for the competition itself is free, although at least 1 member of each team must register for, and attend, the HRI 2018 conference.
Submissions: There is no limit to the number of entries per university or organization. We encourage each student to focus on a single team entry, although students are permitted to join multiple teams.
Expenses: We are communicating with conference organizers now, but thus far, there is no sponsorship or reimbursement available for competition costs, such as developing design prototypes, or for travel or conference registration. We will post an update to this site if funding becomes available.
Jury and Judging: A jury composed of experts in design, robotics and/or interaction will assess each entry during a judging session held at the conference. The jury’s evaluations, plus voting from conference attendees, will determine the winners in several categories of the competition (discussed below).
Submissions and Presentations
Initial Submissions: Student Design Competition teams should prepare an initial submission and submit it via the “paper submission and review” website (deadline: 20th December 2017, noon, PDT). Creating and submitting an initial submission is how student teams enter the competition and indicate that they are working on a project.
Each team’s initial submission should be a 1–2 page abstract, with open format, that includes:
- Project title and authors (names, affiliations, and email addresses).
- An abstract of 100 words or fewer.
- A brief description of the design context, the people involved, and the activities in which they, and the interactive robotic object, will engage. The description can be technical and/or behavioral, but should allow the Chairs to evaluate the proposed or ongoing project.
- One or more rough or refined representative images of the interactive robotic object, which can include hand-drawn sketches, digital renderings, CAD models, and/or photographs.
Camera-Ready Submissions: Teams whose submissions are accepted should submit a 1–2 page camera-ready version by 11 January 2018, updated to reflect the team’s progress to that date, for inclusion in the ACM digital library. The camera-ready version should follow the double-column ACM Proceedings Template – please use the sample-sigconf.tex or ACM_SigConf.docx files.
Presentations: We expect that the Student Design Competition session will coincide with the Demonstrations session, but will announce details later. During the session, student teams will present their interactive everyday objects to the competition jury as well as conference attendees. The form of presentation will be similar to a Technology Demonstration, with each team showing and describing their project as the jury and conference attendees pass by.
At the conference, each team should present:
- A poster or banner (we’ll determine specifications shortly) that includes the project title, authors and affiliations, describes the design concept, shows the interactive everyday object within an interaction context, and includes other background that the team feels is relevant to communicate their efforts. We encourage teams to build upon the content included in their initial and camera-ready submissions.
- Five or more images (renderings or photographs) that show the project in various stages of design development. The first should include the original, unmodified state of the purchased or found object, and the last should show its final, interactive form. The idea is to communicate the team’s design process, including (highlighting!) failures, learnings and successes along the way. While most conference venues emphasize completed works, we celebrate the design process itself.
- Either (a) the interactive everyday object itself to demonstrate in person, or (b) a video that shows the project in context and in action, interacting with people. We strongly encourage teams to bring and show their interactive everyday objects in person, as the most informative and entertaining representation of their work. We understand that some projects may be too large or delicate to travel well, and ask teams in this situation to focus their videos on demonstrating interactions.
Jury and Awards
The HRI community is very diverse, including researchers and practitioners from computer science and engineering, social science, art and design, and a goal of the competition is to be recognize outstanding contributions from any of these disciplines.
We will add further detail regarding jury composition and awards as we learn more about the number and diversity of teams participating. For now, we expect that there will be several awards, representing both juried and people’s choice, along several categories that include interaction, design, creativity, and implementation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Interactive Everyday Objects
Q: What are interactive everyday objects?
A: We want to encourage broad interpretation of what interactive everyday objects might be to each team. They could be custom-built objects or components, repurposed products or furnishings, hacked toys or appliances, or whatever teams have on-hand. We recommend letting the context, people, and interaction guide the design.
Q: Can teams use any hardware or software on their project?
A: Teams may use any physical platform for their interactive robotic objects, and should choose based on their chosen interaction context, the people involved, and the activities in which their objects will engage. To control their interactive robotic objects, teams may use any software platform, open or closed source, or even no software if that suits their design.
Q: Is there any sponsorship for expenses to develop interactive everyday objects, or to attend the HRI conference?
A: We are trying to arrange a way to cover (or to offset) teams’ development expense, and/or attendance expense, but it is still not certain. We will post updates here as we learn more.
Q: How many teams will participate in the competition?
A: Given our initial sense of interest, as well as space available at the conference venue, we plan to select 10 teams to present at the conference. We may change this number based on registration, ideas submitted, or team composition, and will post any changes here.
Q: Can any student be a member of more than one team?
A: Students may join more than 1 team. If only a few students from a lab or institution can attend the HRI conference (for example, due to schedule or expense), it might be more convenient to form larger teams (up to the maximum of 5 members), so that more students can participate.
Q: Can teams be composed of students from different schools?
A: Yes. Just include the (different) school affiliations of your team members in the application materials.
Q: Is there a social platform or service for finding teammates?
A: We don’t have a platform set up to help teams form, although you’re welcome to take the initiative. Let us know, and we will post details here. If we receive enough interest from individuals or small teams, we may collect and send your email addresses to each other.
Q: Can student members join or leave teams after submitting a proposal?
A: Individual members may be added or removed from teams up until 2 weeks prior to the conference. To make such changes, please email the Chairs at firstname.lastname@example.org as soon as possible.
Eligibility and Registration
Q: Can someone who isn’t a student participate?
A: The HRI 2018 Student Design Competition is only open to students, although students at any university level (bachelor’s, master’s, and PhD) may participate.
Q: Can other people, or advisors, help with the competition project?
A: It is alright to seek external help for bugs and other issues, however, people external to the team should not contribute significantly to the project’s ideas or implementation. Advisors may advise on ideas, designs and approach, but team members should be the primary source of conceptual and execution effort in developing the project.
Q: Can a team withdraw after submitting a proposal?
A: Teams are able to withdraw. In this case, please notify the Student Design Competition Chairs at email@example.com at least 2 weeks prior to the conference. For team members seeking reimbursement for conference registration fees, please contact the Registration Chairs at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Q: How many teams will participate in the competition?
A: There is no limit on the number of teams who may enter an initial submission. The Chairs will then select a subset of these submissions as finalists, to prepare camera-ready versions and present their projects during the conference.
The HRI 2018 Student Design Competition Chairs are:
Malte Jung, Cornell University, USA
Sonya S. Kwak, Ewha Womans University, Korea
Hirotaka Osawa, University of Tsukuba, Japan